Skeptic Geek’s Posterous

Mahendra Palsule 
« Back to blog

Aggregators as Scatterers and Why It Matters

Services like Friendfeed are commonly referred to as Aggregators. This is because they allow you to pull in your blog posts, pictures, videos, etc. from various sites into your stream on that service. But from another perspective, that I think should also be noted, aggregators enable fragmentation of the discussion surrounding a topic. This is what I've actually seen happening:

  1. The original blog post leads to comments and interaction on the blog itself.
  2. RSS subscribers use feed readers like Google Reader. They share the article if they like it. Some add their notes as well.
  3. Subscribers 'aggregate' their shared feed items on Friendfeed. These appear as multiple posts on Friendfeed, each leading to individual, separate likes and discussions.
  4. Friendfeed users in turn set their posts to be automatically posted to Facebook, where Facebook users like and comment on the Facebook post.
  5. Friendfeed users also auto-tweet their posts. Their followers on Twitter re-tweet, adding their own individual micro-comments.
In the earlier days, a blogger used to get all feedback on his post, right on his blog. Now, the poor chap doesn't know who is liking, sharing, commenting, and talking about his post. Unless he is a super-savvy social tech geek.

You can integrate Friendfeed comments with your blog, but no such luck for the millions who use Blogger and Wordpress.com. On the one hand, services like Friendfeed are making the blogger's post reach a much wider audience than he could have imagined. Unfortunately, he may not know it at all.

Is this aggregation? It may be from the Friendfeed user's perspective. But from the perspective of the original author, this is scattering of feedback.

To be fair, Friendfeed allows you to link to the original author's blog post (if you've set it in Options). But when tech heavyweights share original authors' ideas via Friendfeed, the community often wants to payback their 2 cents on the topic to the heavyweights - not the original author.

When you are proposing an idea, or an opinion, or a strategy, or a technique, scattered feedback is a big deal. An author likes to get ALL feedback - easily. Today, this is getting more and more difficult.

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (3)

Aug 02, 2009
Wayne Sutton said...
Your post is dead on and does appose some challenges for the non technical individual blogger. Your example happen to me this week with my post about Posterous http://bit.ly/1do2QT - it has 45 retweets, 64 friendfeed comments, 34 tweets, and 27 other comments. The friendfeed comments are not from my friendfeed post but from Steve Rubel repost on friendfeed. I have backtype connect which imports comments onto my blog but like you mentioned for bloggers who use blogger or wordpress.com or event Posterous this is a problem if they would like for all of the social comments to be displayed on their blog or at least notified about them.

I think disqus helps solving some of the problem with trying to keep track of social comments across multiple networks but good luck trying to pull in Facebook likes and comments. I believe that will be the next phase in importing social comments. Also it's a challenge trying to pull in stats from all of the resources, google analytics, likes, retweets, shares .. it's a mess right now.

Aug 02, 2009
Wayne Sutton said...
I came across this firefox plugin that may help: http://greactions.com/
Aug 02, 2009
Wayne, thanks for commenting on my actual post - shows that you really *got* what I was saying! :-)

Wow - the example you cite of your own post is exactly what I'm talking about. I've seen this happen often enough to make my write this. I perfectly empathize with you.

Disqus again is not an option for any Blogger/Wordpress.com sites. Facebook has been nasty in letting other networks gain access to its data. I am hoping that the next phase you talk about does come - it will be a real killer if it does. As you said, it is a mess right now.

Oh, and I installed GReactions. MakeUseOf.com - where I write - 'broke' the news to a larger audience.

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     twitter